Atkins or Stewart? WHIR

[Bobby B 11]

I have garrett atkins, do I drop him for ian stewart?

can ian stewart bring something to the table other than "just" this TEAR he is on right now?

or do you think atkins will turn it around?

leave your post link, ill help as much as i can

[kidsilk]

I would keep Atkins over Stewart. Although Atkins is vastly overrated he is good enough to turn it around and play much better this year and I still think he is better than Stewart.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=389175

[simps984]

You could try selling Atkins low... he does have a name folks recognize. Don't get your hopes up, but I'd bet you could get better than Stewart in a deal.

Care to give your opinion on this trade? viewtopic.php?t=389154

[BALCO All-Stars]

I'm of the opposite opinion...I'd take Stewart over Atkins because Stewart plays 2B...Atkins is a very marginal 3B player anymore.

[wheels]

I would pick up Stewart. Who else could you drop if not Atkins, any other dead weight? I agree, try and move Atkins before he bottoms out. But if all else fails, I like Stewart over Atkins right now. Plus Atkins is a FA to be and his numbers are not too special away from Coors. So a trade in July might make things even worse.

please help...viewtopic.php?t=389071