Wells/Valverde for McLouth/Joba?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

Mixed league, 10 team Dynasty league, 6x6 H2H. I am currently in 3rd place with one lousy closer. A guy offered me Vernon Wells and Huston Street for McLouth and Joba. I am thinking about countering with Wells and Valverde for McLouth and Joba or somehow think of a deal that will get me KRod. What do you guys think about this deal and do you have any other ideas if you dont like it?

So HIS:

Wells
Valverde

for MY:

McLouth
Joba

His Team:

C-Mauer
1B-Lee
2B-Figgins
SS-
3B-Chipper
LF-Ibanez
CF-Wells
RF-Pence
UTI-Teix
UTI-Magglio
BN-Kendrick
BN-B.Molina
BN-Blalock
BN-Rasmus
BN-LaPorta
BN-Ortiz
DL-Reyes

SP-Sanchez
SP-Cahill
SP-Escobar
RP-Street
RP-Valverde
RP-KRod
P-Gonzalez
P-Motte
P-Haren
BN-Meche
BN-E. Santana
BN-Hill
DL-Smoltz

MY TEAM:

C-Pierzynski
1B-Morneau
2B-Roberts
SS-Tulo
3B-Youk
LF-Soriano
CF-Werth
RF-Hawpe
UTI-Hart
UTI-Vlad
BN-McLouth
BN-Stewart
BN-C. Jackson
BN-Hardy
BN-Milledge
BN-Dukes
DL-Doumit

SP-Joba
SP-Pelfrey
SP-Maholm
RP-Putz
RP-Capps
RP-Scherzer
P-Arredondo
P-Lee
P-Wainwright
BN-Saunders
BN-Volquez
BN-Ryan

C

[jweb2244]

I like your idea but would change the hitters part of it. I have been burned with Wells before and would not want him, and on your side, I would give one of your other OF's instead of McClouth. I like the closers part, but IMO K-rod is not worth what you would have to pay for his name value, so I would stick with the closers you are now working with.

Also, thanks for help on mine.

[labardo31]

I would absolutely NOT send Joba and McLouth for Wells/Valverde. That's just a downgrade in talent all around. If I were you, I'd try to deal him Tulo or Hardy for Valverde or another closer of his. I think Tulo is done. Maybe the other manager would value him a bit higher since its a dynasty league.

If you were to send an offer for K Rod, maybe McLouth/Joba for K Rod/B Molina. Molina is probably a better option than Pierzynski until you get Doumit back.

Thanks for the input on my McLouth/Young issue.

[kidsilk]

any help from the Sunday crowd?

[Knicks4ever]

I wouldnt make that trade wells just wouldnt interest me, Id try Mclouth and Joba for Pence and Valverde or Street instead.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=389153