M Young for McLouth, WHIR

[labardo31]

16 team true dynasty league (keep all 25 players), 6x6 roto.

My outfield depth is kinda lacking right now and my 3b/ss spots are ok for now. Another manager is looking for a 3bman and trying to use McLouth as his chip.

I send Michael Young
I receive Nate McLouth

Thanks in advance, and leave a link if you'd like an opinion on an issue of your own.

my roster:
C - Carlos Ruiz
1b - Mark Teixeira, Joey Votto, Travis Hafner
2b - Ian Kinsler
3b - Evan Longoria, Michael Young
SS - Yunel Escobar, Rafael Furcal
OF - Jermaine Dye, Granderson, Bruce, Gerrardo Parra
SP - Greinke, Carpenter, Lowe, Gallardo, Jurrjens, Sheets, Hughes
RP - Lidge, Capps, Masterson, Ramon Ramirez, Guerrier, Meyer

[jcde7ago]

I would say that you have to do that trade. McLouth is a legitimate 20/20 OF'er year in and year out...he won't hit for as good an avg. as Young will, but McLouth's power/speed combo in the OF is much more valuable considering how good your IF is. Great trade for you if it happens..thanks for your help with mine.

[Bobby B 11]

I think so, i really like McClouth in Atlantas line up more than him in the bucs line up. so i expect him to produce more

[tstringe]

Mclouth's value shoots up in the Braves lineup and since you're already satisfied at first you should make this deal for sure.

[kidsilk]

I would do it. Both are exceptional players and should both produce. But, I like McLouth slightly more especially in your league format.

please help my McLouth question:

viewtopic.php?t=389045