granderson/shields for utley/inge

[kickureface]

yahoo h2h 5x5 12man standard
c: vmart
1b: youkilis
2b: kinsler
3b: figgins
ss: alexei
of: ludwick, dunn, inge, quentin
util: utley
bench: asdrubal

2sp, 2rp, 3p
SP: lester, ervin, hamels, joba, bedard, harden
RP: frank francisco, lidge, bell, ryan franklin, jose valverde

is this a good trade?

[A2Kid]

Nope Utley is worth wayy more than that. And Inge is solid too, and sheilds ain't special.