I just need some outside opinios

[mdterpfan511]

a manager countered a trade WITH

Josh Johnson, Luke Scott, Pujols for Crawford, Lincecum, Broxton.

The original trade I proposed was exactly the same except Jered Weaver in place of Johnson. Johnson and Weaver have almost identical stats, and weaver is actually ranked higher.
I have A. Gonzo to replace Pujols and I'd put Crawford at Util. Also, my pitching is kinda weak and I only have 2 closers atm. So... I should accept this trade, right?