Trade Help Needed - WHIR

[yanks0826]

Hey guys, this offer was on my table:

I trade:
Roberts, F. Lopex, and DiceK

I get:
Phillips, Branyan, and Sherrill


Do I do this deal?

[bigslickak]

Seems like a pretty even trade. Do you need more saves? Qualls is injured, right? If you do, I would do, otherwise probably hold off.

Please help? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388887

[sweeper193]

It all depends on how you value Roberts and Phillips. While I personally like Roberts a little better, if you need power Phillips will hit more hrs and if you need saves that definitely take the deal. Otherwise if you're good with power and saves might as well stick with your guys.

[A2Kid]

I pull the trigger yeah, Phillips is born to hit, and sherill is solid top15 closer.

[The_Prodigy]

It's close, but unless your in roto and desperate for saves I wouldn't do it...

I think Branyan is awful and Phillips and Roberts are pretty close while Lopez is very solid and underrated in fantasy.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=388902