Who to keep? WHIR 100%

[Johnny Deuce]

Thanks for your help on mine.

That is tough.

Sizemore - LOCK
Upton - agree with another post - he is still young - AND if he is having a bad year this year, he will rebound next year
Hamels - he shutout LA last night, I think he is coming back. (but Chad is very close behind Hamels)

[bigslickak]

Sizemore obviously, BJ Upton (positional scarcity issue mainly), Bills

If not Bills, then El Cabayo (Lee), but if you keep Bills, then just draft for offensive power and avg. You won't have to worry about steals that much.

[kaiser]

Size, Youk and Lee, with Bills a very close fourth. I just dont like to keep pitchers.

[coma]

Sizemore and Bills for sure. Then it comes down to BJ/Lee/Hamels. Personally, I think I would go with Lee with Hamels closely behind.

Help?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388942&p=3099840#p3099840

[HueyntheNews]

Hamels/Bills depending on how their years finish. one of them is going to be an absolute ace.
Youk (hes only getting better and better. He confuses pitchers like crazy.)
If BJ improves something GODLY in the OF then him, but if it unfortunately continues like this then most def Size, cause hes a monster

[C2ThaLo88]

Definitely Sizemore. Then I'd go Youk and Bills.

[mjoyce103]

Sizemore, Youk and Bills look like the three to me without much doubt!

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=389128

[simps984]

Thx for the reply the other day.. sorry I'm slow on the reply:

Sizemore is the duh answer to keep.
Since it's early to decide, I'd wait and see to decide between Hamels and Bills.
I'd say Youkilis, but how about packaging whichever pitcher you don't keep with Youk and trading for an awesome stud!