Chipper Jones trade help

[metsfan12]

I have 2 offers that I made that I'd like opinions on. This one was thought about forever but the guy never decided so I added in Randy Wells to maybe get him to accept:
Chipper, Cliff Lee, Randy Wells
for
Damon, Billingsly


I was offered Blalock and Dempster for Chipper and countered with this:
Chipper, Ichiro, Wells
for
Blalock, Beltran, Dempster


It is a 12 team 5x5 roto (my team is below) and I am punting saves. I am 10 points ahead of 2nd place in BA and have room to make up in all counting stats. Are both beneficial to me? Which would you prefer if you were me?


Team:
C Mauer
1b Branyan
2b Hairston Jr.
3b Arod
SS Jeter
OF Braun
OF Carlos Lee
OF Ichiro
Util Chipper
Bench Bourn (Have played him over Chipper lately because I need steals)
Bench Nick Johnson (play him at 1b when Branyan faces lefties)
Bench Howie Kendrick
Bench Adam Kennedy
DL Delgado

SP Halladay, Cliff Lee, Vazquez, Lilly, Volquez (DL), Escobar (DL), Randy Wells
RP Soriano