crazy trade offer.....do it? WHIR

[fierro33]

ive been offered this mess:

hanley
hamilton
pena
damon
lidge
sherrill

for my

howard
ibanez
CC

if i did it i would have to drop weiters or derosa along with blalock and barmes...........he also proposed pena/damon/lidge for ibanez

10 team 5x5 h2h non keeper

C Mccann
1b howard
2b phillips
3b Arod
ss Reyes
OF Sizemore
OF Ibanez
OF Ellsbury
Util Mclouth
Pierre
ethier
weiters
Derosa
clint barmes





Lincecum
Sabathia
Peavy
Gallardo
Baker
Slowey
Wandy



Papelbon
Nathan
street
soria


Smoltz DL

[ultrazero]

Geez. I'd take that trade too. Basically the same as the other one. Hanley > Howard. and you get Sherrill as well.

[fierro33]

leaves me even more thin at sp tho........

[ultrazero]

I missed the part where CC is included. Ok, so it's a little different. Basically is Hamilton/Sherrill + added bonus of hanley over howard worth more than CC. You have a pretty stacked rotation. But we don't know the full extent of hamiltion's injury and sherrill is shaky.

So I take back what I said, that's a tough one.

[ultrazero]

I wouldn't say thin.

Instead of 3.5 studs you'd have 2.5 studs + a pretty killer pen.

Gallardo being half a stud.

Is the original Ibanez trade off the table?

[fierro33]

original offer is still there

[fierro33]

i might even get him to maybe throw in mike young for weiters

so it would be

pena
young
damon
lidge

for

ibanez/weiters

[ultrazero]

original trade is a steal, this one is ehh.

[fierro33]

u would give up weiters for young in a non keeper right?

[mcliffy2]

I don't like the original for you. In a vacuum its arguably good, but you've already got Reyes at SS. Reyes/Howard > Hanley/Pena.