What's the best ARod deal ?

[Dr Answer]

5x5 Roto - regardless of position need here are my choices :

Hawpe/Brian Roberts (I add Orlando Hudson)
Dunn/Cliff Lee
Granderson/Peavy

Thanks ! Please go alone on straight value

My lineup :

C - R Hernandez
1b - Pena
2b - Phillips
ss - Scutaro
3b - ARod
MI - Hudson
OF - Alexi Ramirez
OF - Bay
OF - Cameron
OF - Wells
OF - Victorino
U - Figgins

SP - Haren/Weaver/Bedard/Cueto/Wolf/Kershaw

[simps984]

I dont think I make that trade for any of them.

I don't like Hawpe given your lineup, and you don't need Roberts speed.

Peavy seems nice, but pitchers are risky, and you don't need Granderson's speed.

Finally, Dunn only gives you some HR advantage over Arod, and not much. He's deficient in avg, rbi, r, and sb. Cliff Lee is good, but not this good.

Help me? viewtopic.php?t=388849

[Dr Answer]

bump ?