Lincecum for Holiday

[Markus09]

The trade is im giving up Lincecum, Alexi Ramirez and Freddy Sanchez for Matt Holiday, Asdurble Cabrera and John Danks. I have pitcher wise,
Jake Peavy
Rich Harden
Joba Chamberlain
Rick Porcello
Josh Outman
Andrew Miller

This is a keeper league, my keeps so far are
Arod
Hanley
Sizemore
Quentin
Votto

[simps984]

Ya know, I wouldn't do it. Losing Lincecum really weakens your pitching stable, and adding Holliday won't help you that much, as you already have Hanley and Arod. I would be patient with Quentin, Votto, and Sizemore. This is especially true in a Keeper league, where Lincecum has greater value, as the youngest of the "elite" pitchers.

Edit: help me out? viewtopic.php?t=388849

[SpeakerDaad]

I wouldn't either. The Holiday of old is gone in my opinion and Lincecum is an absolute stud and I like Alexi (long term) over Cabrera as well.

[Some Guy 15]

I would keep Lincecum.

[Hit Factory]

If you had stronger pitching I would probably do it, Holliday is getting hot and might get traded possibly to a better hitters park. I always thought Lincecum was overrated so I would deal him, but as the other poster mentioned if you dealt him it would really hurt your staff.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388869

[dloke]

Gotta agree with the crew, esp since A Cab is on the DL for anywhere from 2 to 4 weeks.

Please help: http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388898

[Don G.]

No...you definitely need to keep Lincecum. It's to much of a drop off from Lincecum to Danks.

viewtopic.php?t=388891