Greinke/Either for Ichiro? WHIR

[ultrazero]

I'm not gonna lie. I value Ichiro very highly in fantasy. I believe he is a solid second rounder.

But is offering Greinke and Either too much for him? Thoughts? Will help in return.

I'm down in R, AVG, and SB. Ichiro's bread and butter.

This is my current roster.

Batters
C: Joe Mauer (C)
1B: Mark Reynolds (1B,3B)
2B: Brandon Phillips (2B)
3B: Jerry Hairston Jr. (2B,3B,SS,OF)
SS: J.J. Hardy (SS)
CI: Billy Butler (1B)
MI: Marco Scutaro (2B,3B,SS)
OF: Matt Holliday (OF), Andre Ethier (OF), Brad Hawpe (OF), Magglio Ordonez (OF)
Util: Yunel Escobar (SS)
BN: Miguel Cabrera (1B,3B), Evan Longoria (3B), Willy Taveras (OF), Kurt Suzuki (C)
DL: Pat Burrell (OF)

Pitchers
SP: Zack Greinke (SP), Matt Garza (SP), Josh Beckett (SP)
RP: Jonathan Papelbon (RP), Francisco Rodriguez (RP)
P: LaTroy Hawkins (RP), Jason Isringhausen (RP), B.J. Ryan (RP)
BN: Aaron Harang (SP), Zach Duke (SP)
DL: Edinson Volquez (SP)

[cnasty]

That is way too much id rather have grienke than ichiro

[dooho]

ichiro is a nice player, personally i like power in my OF, i want my speed guys in the MI - that's why i don't own him anywhere, but greinke/ethier >> ichiro

[SpeakerDaad]

I agree Greinke/Ethier >> Ichiro. Plus Ichiro is not getting the SB's this year either....

[TheNephilim]

Are you joking?

[ultrazero]

Are you joking?

No, I'm serious.

I've read a lot around here that Greinke is a sell high guy. Either hasn't really done all that much.

So apparently it's too much.

Is Garza/Either for Ichiro a more even deal?

[ultrazero]

Ethier

[everett1987]

ya thats a lil better but he may not take it, maybe an offer in the middle of those 2 somewhere

[Hit Factory]

Hey man, Garza/Ethier is a fair deal and I would do that in a heartbeat. Greinke might be a "sell high" guy but he will not totally crap out. Granted I don't think he will keep up this insane pace for the entire season but even if he comes back down to earth he might still have 1.5-2 ERA...I would hold onto him.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388869