Good Batter OR Good Pitcher/ which would you rather have?

[oneyeman]

Which would you rather have...??
a Top-ten pitcher ?
OR
a Top-ten Batter ?

My opinion is the batter .. while i love a good pitcher... cause its so hard to find a consistent one.. iam allways worried that if he is having a bad outing your points for that week with this guy are done..even negitive.. But a batter ..well if he has a bad outing ..well there's allways tomarrow ..

What has me thinking about this is i just traded Mauer and aj-burnett for sotto and johan santana..

[yearbend]

id take the batter, you can always stream pitchers if need be.

[Wladimer]

In most leagues theres always one person who tries to win with Pitching... I am that guy.

That said I will not be taking Tim Lincecum above Albert Pujols or Hanley Ramirez. But if I have pick 3-8 I will usually try to trade down so I can get Lince or Santana.