reyes for mclouth WHIR

[fierro33]

reyes could be out for a while.....would u trade him for mclouth?

or would u rather counter with reyes/CC/ibanez for his pujols/beltran

10 team 5x5 h2h non keeper

C Mccann
1b howard
2b phillips
3b Arod
ss Reyes
OF Sizemore
OF Ibanez
OF Ellsbury
Util Pierre
ethier
weiters
Derosa
clint barmes





Lincecum
Sabathia
Peavy
Burnett
Gallardo
Baker
Slowey
Wandy



Papelbon
Nathan
street
soria


Smoltz DL

[Johnny Tuttle]

No to both.

McLouth is one hot month or one hot stretch, and otherwise, he's middling. I'm not a believer.

This is H2H: just get yourself to the playoffs. You'll be fine even without byes with Reyes.

[Airborne24]

Right now I might ask for a little more for Reyes, maybe a starter. The thing is, it was just revealed that he has a torn muscle in one of his legs, so McLouth might be good value, Reyes might not be running when he comes back.

Help? http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=388802

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

no to the mcclouth deal, even after the news of the torn hammy.

if you can pull of the the pujols/beltran deal i'd do it


please help
viewtopic.php?t=388017

[tstringe]

Mclouth isn't a good deal.

I doubt you could get Ibanez out of him but you need to raise your standards on Reyes.

[C2ThaLo88]

I like the Pujols Beltran deal.

[Hit Factory]

Def no to the first trade, I wouldn't even consider it, Reyes will come back and he is way too valuable. The 2nd deal is intriguing but I would still pass.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388869

[bigslickak]

Reyes straight up for McLouth is a definite NO. There are conflicting reports on his injury, yes it is a tear, but a minor tear.

The second deal is intriguing. I think your pitching is good enough to lose CC and still be OK, so I would do it. The only thing is that I would turn around and try to deal Juan Pierre and someone for a mid level SS.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388887

[zazzal87]

no way to the mclouth deal.....pujols/beltran though would be sweet if you could pull that off

[sweettortilla]

Since this is a non-keeper, I wonder what you should do with Sizemore? I would consider moving him if you can. Depending on your record and rank, if you need to move up, he's one to try to package up. You might be able to get a Nelson Cruz for him.

Help with mine?