What do you think about this trade...

[Wiland]

I am sending this...
Send Jorge Cantu, Fla 3B
Send Josh Hamilton*, Tex OF

I am getting this...
Receive Chipper Jones, Atl 3B
Receive Hideki Matsui, NYY OF
Receive Kosuke Fukudome, ChC OF

Would you do this...

Thank you

[Johnny Tuttle]

I wouldn't myself. I would expect to be able to get comparable OFs like that for free off of waivers. And Jones is very injury prone.

[Wiland]

bump

[Some Guy 15]

I wouldn't myself. I would expect to be able to get comparable OFs like that for free off of waivers. And Jones is very injury prone.

I agree, I dont think your getting enough in return.

[Wiland]

Well I declined it and he came back adding Quentin to it.... So this is it now

I am sending this...
Send Jorge Cantu, Fla 3B
Send Josh Hamilton*, Tex OF

I am getting this...
Receive Chipper Jones, Atl 3B
Receive Hideki Matsui, NYY OF
Receive Kosuke Fukudome, ChC OF
Receive Carlos Quentin, Cws OF

Now what do you think.... Is Carlos going to come back... this looks good now but still....