Drop Luke Scott for McCutchen??...WHIR!

[CrashDavisAllStars]

I have Luke Scott on my bench...Do you drop him for the upside of McCutchen?? Leave a link for help...

12 team H2H (normal) 5x5 league- Roster:
C - Russ Martin
1B - Justin Morneau
2B - Jose Lopez
3B - ARod
SS - Jhonny Peralta
OF - Adam Dunn
OF - Hunter Pence
OF - Adam Lind
OF - Juan Pierre
Util - James Loney
Util - Mike Lowell
BN - Kosuke Fukudome
BN - Luke Scott
BN - Mett Weiters
DL - Xavier Nady

SP - CC Sabathia
SP - John Lackey
SP - Erik Bedard
SP - Joba Chamberlain
SP - Klye Lohse
SP - Kevin Millwood
RP - Jonathon Pappelbon
RP - Francisco Cordero
BN - Scott Kazmir

[CrashDavisAllStars]

Bump....Sorry - just looking for a quick couple of responses...

[harvardly]

Yeah I'd do it. Luke Scott is at his peak right now and still not cracking your lineup so what's the point of having him?

If you think you can trade Luke for something better than 2B Lopez or SS Peralta, then you could take the risk and drop one of those guys instead. Depends a lot on how active your league is and how vulnerable your fellow owners are to "sell high" deals ...

[everett1987]

Scot just homered agian. Hes got legit power hasnt he averaged like 1 hr/20 ab in his career? i think hes for real and in that lineup hell have plenty of oppritunities.

help please?

viewtopic.php?t=388543

[saemick]

I'd hold onto Scott. At least while he's hot

please help:

viewtopic.php?t=388552

[Surfs up]

I agree. Scott is hitting . What has McCutchen done? Potential means you haven't done anything. YET!!!

[Some Guy 15]

I wouldnt drop Scott. I would either trade him since his value is high or hold him.
I would keep him for now.

[Cypher74]

Don't think Scott is worth dropping for McCutcheon.

Help?

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388595