Trade offer *WHIR*

[michaelyoung4prez]

Alright, I am commish of the league and I am proposing a trade that the other team wants to do as much as I do. Problem is they are in last last last last place and there is no trade review. Does this seem at all like a questionable trade?

My Branyan/B-Rob/Bourne/Maholm for his Berkman/J. Upton/Hamels

Thoughts? Leave a link...

12 Team Head to Head League
C-McCann
1B-Branyan
2B-B-Rob
3B-Zimmerman
SS-S. Drew
OF-Rios
OF-Hart
OF-Victorino
Util-Bourn
BN-J. Lopez
BN-S. Hairston
SP-Lincecum
SP-Greinke
SP-Harden
RP-Hoffman
BN-Slowey
BN-Edwin J.
BN-Maholm
DL-Webb
DL-Volquez

[Pogotheostrich]

That seems like a straight up ripoff. I would imagine the rest of the teams in the league would throw a fit.

[SDKSman]

yeah lmao i cant belive as commish u would offer that IMPEACHMENT

[michaelyoung4prez]

i mean we discussed it and met in the middle, i didn't blindly offer it. just trying to be legit, that is why I am asking advice

[michaelyoung4prez]

what about B-Rob/Hart/Bourn/Branyan for Berkman/Hamels. His team is so injured its a joke

[ajk23az]

That is a big time rip off in your favor.

If I was in the league and you are the manager I would be pretty upset, especially with no trade review.

[JeepCop]

I think either trade is worthy of a red flag. There is obviously some question in your mind about the validity of the trade because you're asking us about it, right? I'd definitely have a hard time trying to defend that trade if I were the commish.


Lil help?
viewtopic.php?t=388444

[michaelyoung4prez]

Alright everyone chill. I am asking a question to be legit about it. The non-trade review was a decision the whole league made together, we have an email chain to discuss things.

[michaelyoung4prez]

Other offer I am considering making:

Branyan/B-Rob/Bourn/Ubaldo/Hart/Maholm for Berkman/Hamels/Ludwick or J. Upton

I mean isn't that legit? the guys team is very DLed and he can def make a deal that is that heavy on one side

[SDKSman]

yah i hear ya but neither of these deals r close to fair