Arod for Youkilis and luke scott?

[bjmacdow]

I was just offered Kevin Youkilis and Luke Scott for Arod. Here is my offense:

C: Brandon Inge
1b: Nick Johnson
2b: Brian Roberts
3b: Arod
SS: Michael Young
OF: Carlos Lee
OF: Matt Holiday
OF: Denard Span
UTil: Chone Figgins
Util: Michael Bourn

Does this make sense? Or do I keep Arod. I am getting irritated with his average (.250); but I don't think he is all the way back yet. I appreciate any thoughts. Please leave a link. Thanks.

[bjmacdow]

anyone....Buehler?, Buehler?

[angels7777]

to me this is A-Rod for Youkilis so I say NO

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388405&p=3096479#p3096479

[rib217]

I agree....you do not take this offer for Arod, i think its nowhere close


mine: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388407&p=3096482#p3096482

[leonsbrother]

No, this is a terrible trade offer. This is virtually an Arod for Youkilis deal. Luke Scott is his lucky pickup from FA market one week ago.

Please help me back? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388410

[Hit Factory]

As another poster mentioned this trade is really just Arod for Youk, the only possible upside to this deal is that Youkilis could give you a higher average. However I would not make the move, Arod is Arod and is a perennial first round pick...stick with him.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388421

[mw24x]

Well Arod > Youkilis (but it's not that much of a difference)
And he's just trying to sell high on Luke Scott.

Stick with Arod!

Thanks for the help!

[BALCO All-Stars]

Well Arod > Youkilis (but it's not that much of a difference)

WWWHHHAAATTT??? He's right about not taking the deal, but A-Rod >>> Youk...

[mtxdevil]

Absolutely not.

[mrtrumpt]

No. Not even close.