Haren for Youkilis? Fair? WHIR 100%

[clarkw267]

12 team Roto (5x5) Keeper (Keep 6)

Is Haren enough for Youkilis ? Or should I throw in Blake or D Lee? If so should I ask for a 2nd player in return?

FYI : I'm about 100 innings over the projected limit

My Team
C - Napoli
1B - Pujols
2B - F Lopez
3B - Blake (1B)
SS - Guzman
OF - Braun
OF - Ibanez
OF - BJ Upton
UT - Ethier
BN - D Lee
BN - F. Martinez
BN - Bartlett (DL)
DL - Sizemore

SP - J Santana
SP - Haren
RP - Rivera
RP - Rodney
P - Hawkins
P - Wheeler
P - W Rodriguez
BN - Porcello
BN - Hanson

His Team
C - Y Molina
1B - Youkilis (3B)
2B - Roberts
3B - Zimmerman
SS - Hardy
OF - Pence
OF - Granderson
OF - Fowler
UT - Blalock (1B,3B)
BN - Sandoval (1B,3B)
BN - Andrus
BN - G. Beckham

SP - Lackey
SP - Oswalt
RP - Nathan
RP - Capps
P - Chamberlain
P - Volquez
P - J Nelson
BN - Maholm
BN - Richard
DL - Devine

[angels7777]

if the guy needs a pitcher that is a very fair offer - always start lower than you want to pay then work your way up

viewtopic.php?t=388368

[Lenny6]

Thanks for the help on mine. I'd say it is a very fair deal. In a keeper league will Youkilis qualify at 3B next year would be my only question as having Johan and Haren as a 1-2 punch is a nice luxury to have going into next season. But then again Haren has worn down some late in the season the last coouple of years and you will have Hanson or Porcello to consider as keepers as well.

[saemick]

I agree, this is a very fair trade. I personally like your side better, but still a very fair trade.

thanks for the help with mine

[jmlevy]

I find it hard to believe that staff would be 100 innings over the limit. Granted, Santana, Haren, and Wandy are all but guaranteed 200 IP, but Hanson won't make it up prior to ASB and you have four closers...unless you just went through a massive facelift, something seems fishy.

With that said, I like this trade. It seems fair to me, you save the innings and grossly upgrade at 3B.

Make it happen

[clarkw267]

I was rolling with 7 or 8 SPs for most of the season so far. That's how my innings got so high.

Also I'm looking to move Haren before his annual Post ASB crash.

[MadDog36]

3b is your only hole.. You can Windows (PnP) your rotation here on out.