Hamilton for Choo?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

AL ONLY, 10 team, 30 man roster league, 6x6 Roto style, keeper league, can keep up to 5 players per year but it depends on how much each player is worth and the total amount you can keep is 100 dollars. I already have Halladay and Kinsler as both at 50 dollar players so if I keep both of them I can't keep anyone else. But, I have been offered Josh Hamilton for my Shin Shoo Choo. Hamilton is another 50 dollar player so I would have a difficult decision as far as keepers. But, which guy will help me the most this year? Currently in 8th place but moving up quickly.

SO, do I trade Choo for Hamilton? If you need my roster I will leave it later. But, what do you guys think and leave your links. Thanks.

[briane]

Keep Choo. He's hitting cleanup and Hamilton may be out for two months.

posting.php?mode=post&f=26

[futanto]

Because this is roto I would keep choo at this point. Why not try this deal again in 3 weeks or so when he is about 5 weeks away. Still long enough for him to bite maybe.

Please help if you can.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388019&p=3096244#p3096244

[Magnus_CA]

Dang. How do you decide on 5 players to keep from a 10 team, 30 player roster?

I say keep Hamilton. He has trade value and will continue to gain in value as he returns from the DL. I expect Choo will have a rough 2nd half like many young international players do.

Please help? viewtopic.php?t=388372

[clarkw267]

In roto I would say keep Choo. Noone knows how Hamilton will be when he gets back, and there's no way you could keep him over Kinsler or Doc.

Help please
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=388374