Trade Peavy for Kershaw/Ibanez?

[wags87]

Offer outstanding to give up Peavy and get a pitcher plus Ibanez. My team is kind of in need of an outfielder, my pitching sucks and its a keeper league so if I can get Kershaw, a solid pitching prospect, is this worth it? Thanks

[kidsilk]

I would like to see your roster first but without it I would say do it. Ibanez is a stud who always hits 300 and gets 100 RBI and is looking like he is having a career year this year.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=388338

[MadDog36]

Post your roster.

[wags87]

Actually, another offer: Huff and Max Scherzer for Peavy. Thoughts?


Roster:

C Brian McCann
1B Ryan Howard
2B Brian Roberst
3B Pedro Feliz
SS Michael Young
OF Carlos Quention
OF Corey Hart
OF Shane Victorino
UTIL Adrian Gonzalez (1B)
UTIL Brad Hawpe (OF)
UTIL Mike Cameron
Bench: lyle Overbay yadier Molina

P Ubaldo Jimenez (SP)
P Kyle Lohse (SP)
P Andrew Bailey
SP Paul Maholm
SP Jake Peavy
RP Joe Nathan
RP Frank Francisco
Bench: Scott Baker, Brandon McCarthy

[SDKSman]

i like the first deal better but you p staff needs help also

[MadDog36]

You need a 3b bad, is beltre available.

[wags87]

He is available; that is part of my strategy if a trade goes through. Or should I pick him up to replace Feliz regardless?

[wags87]

It would actually be Bedard (or AJ Burnett)/Ibanez that I would receive and I would send Peavy. Sorry to keep updating, but I'm getting offers from a couple of different teams in my league.