Should I trade Beltran?

[yanks0826]

I was offered Rios and Weiters for my Beltran. Do I make this deal?

The guy that offered me this deal also has these players:

Branyan
Loney
Phillips
O. Hudson
Scott Hairston.


Do I make this deal or counter with something else? My roster is listed below.

[jmcampbe11]

Not enough IMO. The only other player of that bunch I like is Phillips, but his injury worries me. I'd probably just keep Beltran.

Help with mine plz - viewtopic.php?t=388134

[yanks0826]

Do you like Beltran even with the issues he is having?

[Box]

Not sure why you're even considering this. Beltran is still head and shoulders above Rios and you've already got Mauer at C. Its a downgrade at both positions. You've got monster bats for a 14-teamer. If anything I'd be trying to upgrade your SP.

[yanks0826]

Not sure why you're even considering this. Beltran is still head and shoulders above Rios and you've already got Mauer at C. Its a downgrade at both positions. You've got monster bats for a 14-teamer. If anything I'd be trying to upgrade your SP.

Yeah, I thought about that. I actually may trade Prince for Peavy. Do you like that deal?

[sha]

i think i'd be holding onto Beltran. nothing that he has jumps out at me. thanks for the input on mine!

[philaphan]

Yeah I would stand pat! Beltran is miles ahead of Rios. I like Phillips on that list but I would rather keep Beltran.

Please help me!
viewtopic.php?t=388333