Beltran/Dice-K for Manny/Halladay? WHIR

[sixer03fan]

The following offer has been proposed to me:

I give: Beltran, Dice-K
I get: Manny, Roy Halladay

I'm actually intrigued. Manny is only out for 1 more month and Halladay would be a great addition to my staff. Beltran has also been slowed by injury lately and I'm worried a trip to the DL is in his future. Would you do this deal if you were me? If not, what should I counter with? Here's my current roster...

non-keeper, daily transactions
10 team, h2h. YAHOO league.
hits, runs, hr, rbi, avg, stls
wins, k's, era, whip, k/9, saves

c. Matt Wieters
1b. Lance Berkman
2b. Chone Figgins
3b. Michael Young
ss. Rafael Furcal
of. Carlos Beltran
of. Carlos Lee
of. Ichiro Suzuki
u. Ryan Braun
bench. Juan Pierre

sp. Chris Carpenter
sp. Felix Hernandez
sp. Dice-K Matsuzaka
sp. Erik Bedard
sp. Roy Oswalt
sp. Chris Young
sp. Ryan Dempster
sp. Edinson Volquez
sp. Tommy Hanson

rp. Brian Fuentes
rp. Chad Qualls

DL. Kelvim Escobar
DL. Troy Percival

[rib217]

I'd take it! As you said Manny is out for another month then he will return and have as much if not more value than Beltran. Halladay over Dice anyday in my book.


mine: viewtopic.php?t=388265

[killerbeez]

Thanks for helping with mine. Hopefully i'll be able to get Peralta back

I would definitely accept the deal. Dice-K doesn't even come close and with Manny back, you'll be laughing at the deal.

[Roger LaFrancois]

Lets see..

Halladay is much greater than Dice-K

At worst Beltran is just a little preferable to Manny (although I really think it is a wash)

I would do the deal a zillion times in my sleep!! Great deal for you.

[mrtrumpt]

Manny and Halladay wins this deal by a mile.

Please help with my topic "Which side wins?"

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

in a heartbeat. you win by a mile