B.J. Upton deal WHIR 100%

[Padres Fan]

I would do the Ibanez/Carp deal, unless you feel you need speed then I would do Vic/Carp

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388241

[3rice]

first thank you for mine.

See if he would trade Victorino for Upton. Victorino plays in a great ballpark, gets you sb's and is batting .295 this year at lead off (runs)

[richiro]

I guess its not a bad deal for you with Phillips. Do you think you can get something decent for Aaron Hill?

[Hit Factory]

I guess its not a bad deal for you with Phillips. Do you think you can get something decent for Aaron Hill?

I was thinking about doing the Brandon Phillips deal, but he has a nagging injury and that scares me off a bit. Upton is actually starting to hit now and I think he will be more valuable than Phillips. I would like to deal Aaron Hill while his value is still high but I would want back Cano, his owner is going to want an arm and a leg for him lol.

[guyincognito]

I like the Manny deal. Upton has been killing you up until now anyway, so what's a few more weeks. If not, I'd try to get Ibanez and Carpenter.

Help?: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388081

[plainyogurt]

A) Manny will once again be a monster, and wants to prove to people his the best. Upton hasnt shown power, but will still you sb's. Do you need sb's?

B and C: I would choose Lilly of carpenter. Lilly will get you the k's, his whip has been good this year, will carp be able to stay healthy?

If you can get Ibanez and Lilly. I would def do that..

If you need sb's then do Victorino...

i would do B or C..Lilly over carp

help me out

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388412

[plainyogurt]

if no deal with sp then

Upton and a MI(not hill)

For Philips and Victorino or Ibanez?????

If so i wouild choose Ibanez

does that sound fair?