Please Help With This Big Trade Offer? WHIR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Jedimindtric]

12 team 5x5 Roto

I give Utley and Kuroda
I get Pedroia, Wainwright and Iannetta

My catchers are Barajas, Flores and Shoppach and we start 2

My team

Barajas
Flores (Shoppach)
Agon
Utley
Peralta
Figgins
MI K. Johnson
CI Blake
UT Giambi
Beltran
Ichiro
Damon
Kubel (Dukes)
Guillen (Royals)

Oswalt
Lee
Lilly
Harang
Lowe
Kuroda
Nathan
Jenks
Qualls

Webb on the Bench with Tallet and Guthrie.

Thoughts?

[pjalst]

I'd pull the trigger on this one before he comes to his senses and changes his mind. I wouldn't be surprised if you get a veto vote or two.

[Swagger]

What categories are you looking for help in? Who are you going to drop if this trade goes through?

Overall I think the trade is pretty good for you - Pedroia and Utley are fairly even - I think Wainright is a step up and you get Iannetta to boot.


Help with mine

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388167

[Jedimindtric]

Probably drop Shoppach Maybe Frenchy

[pre1322]

I like this one for you my friend. It helps you in 2 spots for a small down grade in the other. However, Pedroia is an adequate replacement.

Help? viewtopic.php?t=388068

[Jedimindtric]

Thanks for your responses. I believe I responded to all of yours. Anyone else?

[angels7777]

while Utley is the best player here, you potentially fill 3 gaps so it is probably worth it - the guy who said this might get vetoed is crazy

viewtopic.php?t=388172

[Jedimindtric]

Anyone else? I am torn here. Everyone seems to think this is a good trade. Utley should have double the HRs, 30-40 more Rbis and close to the SBs. I really like both Wainwright and Iannetta though too. Help!!!!!!!

[pjalst]

while Utley is the best player here, you potentially fill 3 gaps so it is probably worth it - the guy who said this might get vetoed is crazy

viewtopic.php?t=388172

read carefully my friend, I didn't say it would get vetoed. I said it May get a veto vote or two.

[JohnnnyD]

I think this is a good trade. yes i know giving up utley will suck but pedroia will boost your avg a little as long as u got the power to cover for what youll lose with utley. wain will put up some good numbers pitching as well

help
viewtopic.php?f=29&t=388161