I proposed this...WHIR

[Papelbon Fire]

I'm in a 12 team Yahoo 5x5 and I proposed this trade..Am I giving up too much? Is this fair?

My:
Utley & Werth
for
His:
Pedroia & Scott

Rest of my team:
C-Wieters, Barajas
1B-Howard, Johnson
3B-Branyan
SS-Al.Ramirez, Bartlett(DL)
OF-Hunter, Hairston Jr., Granderson
SP-Halladay, Lester, Dice K, Price, Floyd, Zito, Richmond
RP-Wilson, Downs, Ra. Ramirez

[plainyogurt]

scott puts up nice numbers, but he is pretty hot right now, and wouldnt expect that to last..Werth will get better and Utley is better offense than Pedroia...

giving up too much for a hot hitter right now and perdroia..I wouldnt do that.

Are you a phillies fan(utley and werth) cause if you are im gonna have to delete my post


Help me out

viewtopic.php?t=388155

[Guzman24]

way too much. keep utley

Mine: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388149

[pre1322]

Keep what you have. Scott did the same thing last year and Pedroia has more name value than true value IMO. Utley and Werth are more consistent and always come around.

Help? viewtopic.php?t=388068