*EDIT* Beltran or Utley for Greinke straight up? help ASAP

[rib217]

deal on the table at the moment Beltran for Greinke straight up. Do i pull the trigger?

***EDIT***: I also proposed to a different manager Utley for Greinke straight up? is that a good deal for me? slanted to much in my favor? not enough for Greinke?


12 team roto non-keeper 7x7 R Hr Rbi Sb K Avg Obp W L Sv K Era Whip Qs

C- Pablo
1b- Morneau
2b- Castillo
3b- Miggy
Ss- Jeter
Of- Lee; Rios; Hart
Ut- Agon; Pierre
Bn: Furcal; Peralta; Reimold

SP: Greinke; Shields; Gallardo; Young; Carpenter; Escobar DL
RP: Gonzalez; Hoffman; Downs; Hawkins

[Philly_05]

No way should you trade Grienke for that little.

help on mine?
viewtopic.php?t=388078

[dagactor]

I wouldn't. Greinke is a stuuuuud. Beltran is iffy with the injury and I think Hart will turn it around and have similar 2nd half #'s.

Mine: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388088

[jmcampbe11]

I agree. I'd want more. Beltran's lack of power is disturbing and he's always an injury risk.

[rib217]

bump

Utley straight up?

Beltran straight up?

[TeamMikeDeveraux]

I would take Utley for Greinke straight up. Both should be studs from here on out.

Help? viewtopic.php?t=388160

[JohnnnyD]

Greinke is a stud yes but he won't keep these numbers up for the whole season. right now i think you could definitely get more than just utley straight up for Greinke considering he is dominating right now. Utley for Greinke may pan out an even trade in the end of the season but right now you could get more.

help
viewtopic.php?f=29&t=388161

[Guzman24]

take utley and run. great sell high. yes, grienke is a stud and has been stellar all year but utley has been stellar for many years.

Mine: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388149