I agree with the majority in saying that if Davis gets out of his funk then he will be a beast. Let's hope that doesn't happen though since I own Blalock...lol
Out of the 2 closers though I would definately go with the more proven guy in She......just kidding!...lol You have to go with CAPPS here. Even though the injury still makes him a little iffy he did have a save the first game back (without it being fully healed). Although the save looked horrible and he got lucky with it, it still goes down in the books as a win (save).
I do disagree with everyone here though regarding Sherrill and the fact that he sucks? and that he will lose his job to Ray and all?....Sherrill has been nothing but studly ever since his demotion over a month ago. All he needed was that spark and the demotion word stuck in his head and he has been great ever since. Ray has been nothing but horrible, sent to the minors and from what I heard, even though it's only been a few days he's been there, I heard he has stunk it up there as well. (No way Ray becomes Fantasy relavent this season).
So.....I would grab Capps over Sherrill but if I were you then why not try both for Davis and if not then both for Davis and a crappy WW throw in (if you have any of those)!