Trade Greinke + ?? for Beltran + Cano?? WHIR Asap

[rib217]

I am loving Greinke, but also wonder if his value is at a point where I can get a really good return. Please help me decide if this deal is good enough for Greinke, or if I should try for somebody different (Utley). Will losing Greinke hurt my pitching too much?
The owner offered Beltran straight up for Greinke but I would like to get Cano as well. Sorry its a bit long; but leave a link, I absolutely will return the favor!!!

I give: Greinke; L. Castillo
I get: Beltran; Cano

should i just go Greinke for Utley straight up? (different owner)

12 team roto league non-keeper 7x7----R Hr Rbi Sb K Avg Obp W L Sv K Era Whip Qs
He is in last place with worst ERA and WHIP in the league

My team vs His team
c- Sandoval-----Soto
1b-Morneau-----Helton
2b-Castillo------Cano
3b- Miggy--------Huff
ss- Jeter---------F. Lopez
of- Lee----------Hamilton
of- Hart---------Beltran
of- Rios---------Vlad
ut- Agon--------Youkilis
ut- Pierre-------Werth

My bench: Reimold; Peralta; Furcal
His bench: Cameron; Harrison; Crisp

My SP: Greinke; Shields; Gallardo; Carpenter; Young; Escobar DL
His SP: Bedard; Dice K; Pettite; Washburn; Lowe; Harden DL

My RP: Hoffman; Gonzalez; Downs; Hawkins
His RP: Lindstrom; Rodney; Valverde

[eric31216]

i would try the utley deal first before doing the greinke + for beltran and cano.

help please? viewtopic.php?t=388038

[mw24x]

I like either trades for you. Your pitching staff is pretty solid and 2B is definitely your weakest position. I think getting both Beltran and Cano would be a fair price for giving up Greinke.

[Lil' Doug Dascenzo]

Both deals would be great for you, but I'd make a run at Utley.

[Some Guy 15]

Thanks for the help.

Yes, I like both trades since you will still have some great pitching.

Try the Utley trade first,,,, I like that one better

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

your pitching staff can definitely handle the loss. I actually like both trades, but unlike everyone else i'd go after the beltran/cano deal. Yes, utley is the better player of the 3, but beltran/cano helps you in more areas than just utley. if he declines the beltran/cano deal you can always fall back to the utley deal, which is probably more realistic anyway


thanks for the help with mine

[mcliffy2]

I would try for the Utley trade, although it does leave some risk in your staff (Carpenter staying healthy, Young is unpredictable). Seems your league has smaller benches - what SP are available that you could pick up?