Trade Webb for Upton? WHIR!

[Fender1114]

I've just been offered Justin Upton for Brandon Webb. I could use the offensive firepower, and this is a KEEPER league. Good trade?

10 team, standard roto (QS, not Wins)

MY TEAM:

C: B. Molina
1B: J. Morneau
2B: B. Phillips
3B: M. Lowell
SS: M. Young
OF: Ca. Lee
OF: A. Dunn
OF: J. Pierre
UTL: M. Bourn
B: K. Fukodome
B: O. Hudson
B: M. Scutaro
B: W. Taveras
B: P. Konerko

SP: J. Santana
SP: J. Verlander
RP: F. Rodriguez
RP: C. Qualls
RP: F. Rodney
RP: R. Soriano
P: Cl. Lee
B: R. Wolf
B: M. Buerle
DL: B. Webb

[yanks0826]

Yes, I would do this deal, you have solid SPs.

Help me?

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=387972

[Knicks4ever]

yeah do that, upton is worth his weight in gold in a keeper

viewtopic.php?t=387956

[woowoo crew]

i would say don't do it if you didn't have solid pitching already. you've been without webb all season, so i think it's a good deal. however, with webb's name and known skills, i think you could ask him to throw in a pitcher with upton. if not, i still like the deal. not sure how good webb will be whenever he comes back.

help me please: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=387964

[Holein1]

Do this in a heart beat. after that...obviously you are winning in SB....trade one of your SB guys for a upgrade in pitching.

please help

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=387976

[SecretAgentMan]

I would do it. You get a known quantity for a guy that has been hurt all year.

[rasto21585]

Your pitching is solid. It would benefit you more to get upton.

[bigjay0329]

I agree with everyone. Good trade. Coming back from a shoulder injury you won't know what you get. Justin is a stud

[BALCO All-Stars]

Tough choice. Upton should be a stud, but he has only had a good month (look at his splits) and Webb (when healthy) is a top 5 pitcher. How many players do you keep? Perusing your team I'd say Morneau, Phillips, Carlos Lee, and Santana are LOCKS, with Verlander a no-brainer, and if you freeze even more, F-Rod fits the bill...so how many do you keep?