Cruz and Ethier deal WHIR

[Knicks4ever]

Should I trade B.Morrow and A.Ethier for Shin-Soo Choo in a 6x6 10 team 10 player keeper league? (OBP and Quality Starts are the extra categories)

[sigriffey]

I don't think Morrow is a huge factor, so this is a decent deal. The only thing is that Ethier could heat up again when Manny returns, so that is something to consider and Ethier and Choo have similar numbers.

[angels7777]

I would stay put - Choo is not necessarily better than Ethier and Morrow at some point could close again

viewtopic.php?t=387919

[Fender1114]

Nah I would stand pat. Morrow will figure things out eventually, and Eithier and Choo are pretty equal value so you don't gain much there.

[Knicks4ever]

anyone else?

[Hit Factory]

I would not make this deal, I agree with the other poster...when Manny returns he will help Ethier get back to where he was before he was suspended.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388236

[Knicks4ever]

What about for Nelson Cruz not Choo?

[ceLpH]

Id stick with Either regardless of if its for Choo or Cruz... Either hits in the better lineup (though Texas can rake) & once Manny comes back and provides the protection I expect his average to be 300+ from there out like he started off this year

viewtopic.php?t=388246

[saemick]

What about for Nelson Cruz not Choo?

Yes for Cruz, no for Choo

Baiscally Ethier may or may not hear up once Manny returns...but if he does, it's not going to be until next month anyway. Choo is slightly better than Ethier now, but it's kind of a wash to me. Cruz has been great, and should keep it up once that band box in TEX heats up too!

pleaes help:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=388247

[Knicks4ever]

anyone else have thoughts on the cruz trade?