Trade Offered (Mauer/Miggy for Halladay/Chris Davis)

[briane]

7 team AL only. I need pitching.

I give:
Joe Mauer
Miguel Cabrera

I get:

Roy Halladay
Chris Davis
Jason Isringhausen
Glen Perkins

Avg. is not a category, OBP and SLG are; I have a substantial lead in OBP, and am replacing Mauer with Wieters. Is this still too much to give up?

[woowoo crew]

yes, i think it's too much. i'd offer mauer and someone else for halladay straight up. do you have a pitcher you don't really need to keep?

help me please: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=387905&p=3093394#p3093394

[briane]

If I substituted Nick Markakis for Pat Burrell for Miggy and Chris Davis?

Or Bobby Abreu for Pat Burrell?

[briane]

bump

[briane]

any other thoughts?

[angels7777]

M-Cab side wins easily

viewtopic.php?t=387919

[woowoo crew]

i'm not sure what your new proposal is. the guys you mentioned the 2nd time weren't in the first deal. (burrell, abreu, markakis)
clarify please.

help me on a new one please: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=387964

[briane]

Clarification:

instead of sending Cabrera and getting back Chris Davis, he's willing to take Markakis and get back Pat Burrell.

My feeling is I am willing to slightly overpay for pitching, but this is ridiculous. And I can't make it.

[woowoo crew]

i'd trade abreu before markakis. so you're looking at mauer and abreu for halladay and burrell? that is more even than miggy/mauer. halladay is a top 3 pitcher, so if you need it, go for it. i'm curious as to what other outfielders he has though.

did you look at mine? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=387964

[briane]

I'd make that deal too. he turned down Abreu and wanted Markakis instead. That's why I think I'm going to say no. Here are the offers:

Joe Mauer & Miguel Cabrera
for
Chris Davis (or Mike Jacobs) & Roy Halladay & Izzy & Glen perkins

2) Mauer & Markakis
for
Halladay, Burrell, Izzy & perkins