Is this a fair offer? WHIR!!

[Bea Arthur]

the guy i want to trade with is an absentee manager. he hasn't done a thing since the draft. our commissioner told us we could offer trades that were fair, and the league would vote. he'd make the roster moves.

would it be smarter to go after ryan zimmerman and matt kemp instead of reynolds and granderson? kemp is a downgrade from granderson, while zimmerman is an upgrade to reynolds.

Yeah, I like that deal better for you. Go for it.

Help w/mine?

viewtopic.php?t=387910

[kaiser]

Agreed that is you can give up jurJens, than getting Granderson is a nice upgrade. On firstgalce, i say make the deal.

Thanks for your help.

[sigriffey]

Propose it as is -- if he balks, then swap in Cueto. It is a solid deal and Granderson is a nice guy to have. Fuko could have a terrible second half again..

[angels7777]

it seems like a solid offer to me - essentially Davis and Reynolds should put up similar stats and you gt Ganderson for Jurrjens and the offer comes across as fair

viewtopic.php?t=387919