Trade Votto/Reynolds/Hill/Kemp for Utley/Sizemore/Harden

[wyld stallions]

What do you guys think?? Or should I try Hill/Reynolds for Utley/Smoltz?

12 team, h2h, 3 man keeper

Scoring:
H, 2, 3, hr, R, RBi, BB, Ave. OBP, SB, SO, E
W, L, CG, SHO, SO, BB, HR, ERA, WHIP, SV, BSV

My team:
C: B Molina
1st: Teixeira, Votto
2nd: Hill
3rd: Wright, ARod, Reynolds (1,3)
SS: JJ Hardy, Scutaro
OF: Bay, Hart, Kemp, Dye
SP: Hamel, Haren, Vazquez, Cueto, Webb (DL),
RP: Soria, Francisco, Bell

His team:
C: Martinez (1,c), Varitek
1st: Lee
2nd: Utley, Polonco
3rd: Huff (1,3), Rolen
SS: Tulowitzki
OF: Sizemore, span, Ludwick, Matsui

SP: Jurjens, Harden, Pettite, Peavy, SMoltz (DL)
RP: Capps, Down, Ryan, Street, Putz

[Dem' Cowboys]

Thanks for the help with mine. I would definitely try it, but I'd imagine he'll say no. I like Smoltzy and Utley over Hill and Reynolds for sure. Is the other owner a Dodger fan? I've seen some crazy dodger fans do some desperate trades..

[MadDog36]

That mega trade works nciely. Get rid of Reynolds and his record setting K-rates. Hill nice sell high, though I think he's legit. Utley is a huge upgrade. Sizemore is a nice buy low right naod too good to struggle forever right. Harden nice buy low as well. If you have any DL you'll really come out the winner.

Wright, Arod, Utley, Tex shit man what are you trying to do rub it in eh?

[wyld stallions]

I like the mega-trade but I do not like getting rid of Kemp. I think I will go for Harden over Smoltz also. I talk to the guy last night at a bachelor party and he said he is interested in trading. The biggest problem is I could not keep all four guys. I would have to choose 3 or try to trade for an upgrade. I just do not see too many upgrade keepers

[Tireur]

I like it if he goes for it. You don't really lose much and you get a major upgrade at 2nd, OF, and SP.

[wyld stallions]

Even now that SIzemore is on the DL?? Should I offer Dye instead of Kemp?

[Tireur]

Yeah now that he's on the DL you could probably get away with Dye instead.

[Magnus_CA]

I like the original deal as is or try rubbing in the fact that Sizemore is out for 2 weeks. Don't forget Votto just hit the DL too though.

Please help? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=387886

[wyld stallions]

What if I offer Hill/Votto/Kemp/Reynolds for Utley/Sizemore/Harden/Smoltz. I am not sure he will give up both SP, but I really like Kemp.