Zimmerman/Phillips for uggla/jones/rios?

[JohnnnyD]

I was offered zimmerman and brandon phillips for my Dan Uggla, Chipper Jones, and Alex Rios. Uggla and Jones are my starting 2b and 3b and my outfield is in pretty good shape as I have Alex Rios, Matt Kemp, Bobby Abreu, Carlos Lee, and Shane Victorino.

Should I accept this trade or offer him Abreu instead of rios or what? Any thoughts or suggestions would be helpful.

Thanks, leave links WHIR if possible

[kidsilk]

I wouldn't do it. I think you are giving up too much. I might do it if you could give up Abreu instead of Rios but it is still iffy.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=387455

[JohnnnyD]

anyone else?

[Hit Factory]

Hey, thanks for the help with mine! I agree with the previous poster, I think you are giving up a bit much, and I think Rios will keep on improving this season and will be pretty valuable especially if he can steal some more bases.

[SumG]

I'd be ok making this deal. Its all well and good to have faith in the guy you drafted, but there comes a point you have to cut the cord on a guy like Uggla.