Prince Fielders Trade Value

[cdawg4343]

I've been offered Derossa and Broxton for Prince. I'm just trying to get a gage on his value. The owner also has Cano and I'm in need of a 2b. Didn't know if Cano and Broxton was enough in return for fielder, I need 2b and rp help. 14-team h2h 5x5 redraft league.
My team:
c. Soto
1b. Pujols
2b. Polanco
ss. Jeter
3b. Reynolds
lf. Holliday
cf. McClouth
rf. Markakis
ut. Fielder
b. Bruce, Nady (DL)
sp. Sabathia, Peavy, Billingsley, Meche, Ubaldo, Sanchez, Dice-K, De La Rosa
rp. Rivera, Hawkins, Marmol, Izzy, Hanrahan

[RowdyRed]

I'm not a fan of Fielder. So.....I would probably be willing to take Cano and Broxton for Fielder, but I could see asking for more. I may take Derosa and Broxton given your situation.

[Ender]

He is leading the NL in RBI and has 12 HR even with a slow start. That seems like a pretty weak return for Fielder.

[BillyHallDisciple]

Fielder is on pace for 37 hr & 151 rbi (Heck, in tonight's game he's 3-for-4 with a homer and 3 RBI). Broxton and DeRosa? Please. Cano and Broxton? You're still getting the short end of that trade. I don't understand why Prince has so many critics, the dude is a masher and he hasn't batted lower than .270 in a full season.

Has anyone ever seen Cano or DeRosa on that kind of pace?

[richiro]

Would you guys trade Carpenter for Fielder?

[BillyHallDisciple]

Yep.

[the izzy]

ya, poor trade. Fielder still has top 40 value (at least. I wouldn't settle for anything less).

As for the other guy, Prince >>> Carpenter IMO. Carpenter is a great pitcher and maybe even top 10 when healthy, the problem is that he's hardly ever healthy. I would venture to guess that he has under 20 starts be the time the season is over.

help me? viewtopic.php?t=387811

[eric31216]

fielder is the better value

viewtopic.php?t=387763 help plz