Who wins this 8 player deal?

[Plus1Plus1]

Player A gives:
1b Carlos Pena
2b Orlando Hudson
SP Tim Lincecum
SP Matt Cain

Player B gives:
1b Joey Votto
2b Dustin Pedroia
SP Justin Verlander
SP Ervin Santana

Just curious who gets the most value in this deal, and if people think it is close at all.

[Padres Fan]

Keeper league wise Side B has more value, in a regualr league, I stick with side A, Votto this year seems very prone to dizzy spells and E Santana is still working his way back, Verlander is starting to turn around, where as this season Pedroia and Hudson should finish pretty similar, but like I said if it was a keeper league I might do it the only deal breaker is Lincecum.


help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=387614

[Rbsurf]

I like what B gets

I really think Santana wont put up those numbers we saw last year..Cain is finally putting everything together..He just needs run support..Lincecum is one of the best..Pena's power and Hudson avg and other..

Help me out please

search.php?search_id=egosearch

[coma]

Pedroia, Votto, and Verlander won me over. I have all three on my team and all have been great. Plus, they're all young! B wins.
Thanks for the help!

[col24]

Think the B team gets the best of it, but its def not a lopsided trade at all


help here

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=387674

[htmt519]

I like side B. Verlander did it for me. But I agree with the others, it's not lopsided. I don't know which one you are, but I'd be happy with either package.

viewtopic.php?t=387677

[reverend]

That looks more even than most trades. Why even do it?