Morneau/Johan for ARod/Haren/Nathan? WHIR

[coma]

I had originally proposed my Greinke/Aram/Reynolds for Arod/Nathan and got this counter offer. My Morneau/Johan for ARod/Haren/Nathan. What do you guys think? Anything I should re-counter with? I was kinda hoping to give up 3 and get 2 so I could pick up Slowey or Scherzer.

8 team H2H league (non-keeper).
Hitter cats are R/H/HR/RBI/SB/AVG/OBP.
Pitcher cats are IP/W/SV/HR/K/ERA/WHIP.

C- McCann (Atl - C)
1B- Morneau (Min - 1B)
2B- Pedroia (Bos - 2B)
3B- Reynolds (Ari - 3B)
SS- Jeter (NYY - SS)
OF- Sizemore (Cle - OF)
OF- Lee (Hou - OF)
OF- Pierre (LAD - OF)
Util- Votto (Cin - 1B)
BN- Rios (Tor - OF)
BN- Wieters (Bal - C)
DL - Ramirez (ChC - 3B)

SP- Santana (NYM - SP)
SP- Billingsley (LAD - SP)
RP- Fransisco (Tex - RP)
RP- Ball (SD - RP)
P- Downs (Tor - RP)
P- Lidge (Phi - RP)
P- Greinke (KC - SP)
BN- Bedard (Sea - SP)
BN- Verlander (Det - SP)
BN - Oswalt (Hou - SP)

His team:
Doumit
MCab
Cano
ARod
Zobrist
Markakis
Abreau
Beltran
J. Upton
Tavaras
Delgado
Burrell

Halladay
Haren
Nathan
Soria
Bailey
Lester
Zambrano
Duke
Saunders
Duchscherer

[Padres Fan]

I would do it then shop Lidge and Downs for a pitcher and another 1B maybe someone underrtaed like Loney, you still have Billingsley and Greinke who are studs and verlander is doing great as well. plus Haren is no slouch as well.


help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=387614

[Plus1Plus1]

I think you get great value out of this trade. You patch that hole at 3b, and give yourself a valuable piece to move in the future (one of your RP's).

halp? http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=387655

[lyons595]

Do it. It hurts to lose Johan, but you arguably the best player in teh game, a stud SP, and a stud RP. You can use Votto at 1B and use ARam/Reynolds for the util spot.

[col24]

I would def do it! Haren is still a SOLID ace, its not like you are gettin a #2 pitcher back, so the drop off won't be huge. AROD will be better than Morneau obviously from here on out, and Nathan is the icing on the cake!

help here please

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=387674

[coma]

Would it be better for me to receiver ARod/Haren/Nathan or should I see if I can get ARod/Halladay for the same package?

[RedDunce]

Would it be better for me to receiver ARod/Haren/Nathan or should I see if I can get ARod/Halladay for the same package?

Given your lineup, I'd go for A-Rod/Haren/Nathan, then try to shop Lidge or Downs as already mentioned. Halladay is filthy, that's true, but so's Haren - and Nathan is very valuable for your team.

[bosoxrock34]

I like the value but damn u will have a log jam at 3b

[METS 24]

Deleted

[coma]

About to accept. Do I drop Downs or Reynolds or Wieters? It would probably be Reynolds but Votto isn't really healthy right now..