E. Santana/Ordonez for Dice-K/Cruz...100% WHIR

[philaphan]

I was just offered:

MY: E.Santana/Ordonez
for
HIS: DICE-K/Cruz

I think I am going to take this but I wanted to see what other people on the board thought! Santana & Dice have both been shaky and both are injury risk. I think Cruz is much better than Ordonez. Yeah Cruz is hot right now and he probably cool off some but I think he will end up with better numbers than Ordonez at the end of the season.

The other manager really wants Santana and I was thinking of countering with:

MY: E. Santana/Ordonez
for
HIS: DICE/Holliday

MY questions are...should I take the first deal? should I counter with Holliday? or should I stand pat? Advice please....100% WHIR just leave a link!

Here is my roster:
10 Team Head2Head 5X5
C:Suzuki
1b:Berkman
2b:Phillips
3b:Reynolds
SS:Rollins
OF:Braun, Crawford, Ibanez
Util:Lind
BN: Ordonez, Atkins
DL: Posada
SP:Peavy, Grienke
RP: Soria, Downs
SP/RP: Santana, Danks, E. Jackson
BN: C. Young, Scherzer

[linberg]

go ahead and try for holliday if he wants santana that bad. that would be a definite winner. is this a keeper league ?

mine
viewtopic.php?t=387645

[philaphan]

non keepr....redraft!

[Philbo135]

Do It. Ordonez is not producing much(i've got him too) and you can always turn around and flip Cruz or Dice-K if they don't work out for you.

[Philly_05]

Cruz is playing really hot now Ordonez is more or less lost. I would not make a trade for Dice K at this point and would rather have Santana. If you can get a different pitcher from him try that or try something smaller for just Cruz if you really want him.

[patthebat]

Definitely do the Holliday trade if he'll go for it.