Kinsler,Dice K,Granderson for Utley, Scherzer, Jeter?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

Mixed league, 10 teams, redraft, 6x6 H2H with OPS and QS. I have been offered the following:

His:

Ian Kinsler
Curtis Granderson
Dice K
Jason Bartlett

for MY:

Chase Utley
Max Scherzer
Kevin Slowey
Derek Jeter

Should I accept this or counter offer? If so, can you think of any offers I could send out?

MY Team:

C-B. Molina
1B-AGon
2B-Utley
SS-Jeter
3B-Beltre
OF-Holliday
OF-Braun
OF-C.Lee
UTI-Hart
BN-Ortiz
BN-Choo
BN-Taveras
DL-Burrell

SP-Billingsley
SP-Gallardo
SP-Greinke
SP-Slowey
SP-Beckett
RP-Ziegler
RP-Cordero
BN-Scherzer
BN-Maholm
BN-Danks
BN-Lindstrom
BN-Marmol

His Team:

C-Y. Molina
1B-Lee
2B-Utley
SS-Zobrist
3B-Longoria
OF-Granderson
OF-Kemp
OF-Magglio
UTI-Rios
BN-Loney
BN-Quentin
BN-Hill
DL-Bartlett

SP-Dempster
SP-Wakefield
SP-Dice K
SP-Parra
SP-Wolf
RP-Qualls
RP-Gregg
BN-Harang
BN-Garland
BN-J. Johnson
BN-Ryan

[kidsilk]

can anyone help me out on this one? Leave your links. Thanks.

[Guzman24]

I would do it i think.

Utley and Kinsler are basically a wash, just pray Kinsler stays healthy.

You get a nice upgrade in the OF with Granderson and your pitching remains stacked with Bills,Gallardo,Grienke and a solid supporting cast .

Bartlett has more upside than Jeter too imo so i like that part too.

Great trade

Mine please if you can: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=387432

[A817]

I would do this trade, but it tough. You get granderson along with kinsler (who probably cancels utley out). Dice K will be better than he has shown.

thanks for the help on mine. I have another post also

viewtopic.php?t=387462

[WhipperSnappers44]

Thanks for the reply.....I would do this trade as well. Getting Grandy and Kinsler basically for Chase is a steal and Dice-K will turn things around.

Good Luck!

WhipperSnappers44!!!

[philaphan]

I like your side of this deal! I agree with everyone that Dice will turn it around! Do the deal!

Thanks for the help with mine!

[kidsilk]

anyone else have an opnion? I am leaning towards doing it but it is tough to give up Utley.

[sigriffey]

Do it because Kinsler plays in that band box and Bartlett has more upside than Jetes.

[MarkakisMVP]

I wouldn't do it. Bartlett is maxed out and now on the DL, Jeter will be better for the year. Kinsler and Utley are essentially a wash, slight edge to Kinsler. That leaves you with Granderson and Dice-K for Scherzer and Slowely.

I'd try trimming it down to at least that and probably even go further with just Scherzer or Slowley for Granderson. You have no need for Dice-K.

[Some Guy 15]

I think you should do it, and I understand giving up Utley is tough.

Could anyone help me out? viewtopic.php?t=387496