Sabermetrics League and I picked up Weiters...do this Trade?

[Jimas21]

I just picked up Weiters. I have Soto in the catchers spot now but he's not doing much. Worth it in my opinion to trade him and take a chance on Weiters. I tried trading Soto straight up for Lidge to help my saves. The guy countered with Lidge and Pablo Sandoval for Joakim Soria and Soto. Is this worth doing? I know Soria's hurt so thats a question mark, but Lidge is playing mind games again. Here's my lineup as of the moment:

C - Soto
CI - Texiera
CI - Zimmerman
MI - Hardy
MI - Hudson
OF - Braun
OF - C. Lee
OF - Abreu
Util - Span
BN - Collaspo
BN - Weiters
BN - Loney

SP - Johan
SP - Felix Hernandez
RP - Nathan
RP - Hanrahan
P - Lohse
P - Carpenter
P - Lilly
DL - Volquez
DL - Soria

[youngcapitalist]

I wouldn't do it. You don't need Soto since you have Weiters so he's basically worthless in the deal. Lidge is stinking it up and Soria appears to be getting healthy without much issue/should have a much better season than Lidge if he stay that way. JC Romero also coming back to the pen for the Phils this week or next so I think Lidge needs to watch his job.