C Hart, A Hill, & C Davis 4 M Holliday, & R Branyan

[pappymojo]

Would that trade sound fair? Think it has a shot of being accepted?

My hitters are as follows:

C Wieters
1B Berkman
2B Hill
3B Davis (1B/3B)
SS Rollins
OF C Lee, C Hart, M Ordonez
Util Adam Jones
Bench Alexei Ramirez (2B/SS/OF)

His Hitters are:

C Suzuki
1B Votto
2B DeRosa (2B/3B/OF)
3B Branyan (1B/3B)
SS Jeter
OF Soriano, Holliday, Bradley
Util Francoeur
Bench Sanchez, Ethier

[jmcampbe11]

I think you're giving up too much. Holliday's not the same player. And is Branyan really any better then Davis? He's not going to hit .300.

[wyld stallions]

There is no way I would do that trade. You are way over paying. Holliday is a good not great player