Reyes for BJ Upton and Alexei Ramirez?

[Bea Arthur]

I was offered Lind, S. Drew and Zambrano for Reyes. I'm thinking about countering with Upton and Ramirez for Reyes instead. Is that a fair deal and more to the point, a good deal for me? He probably wouldn't accept, but his team is near last place in a 20 team keeper league, so maybe he'd do the deal in hopes for having Reyes next year too.

[skones]

I was offered Lind, S. Drew and Zambrano for Reyes. I'm thinking about countering with Upton and Ramirez for Reyes instead. Is that a fair deal and more to the point, a good deal for me? He probably wouldn't accept, but his team is near last place in a 20 team keeper league, so maybe he'd do the deal in hopes for having Reyes next year too.

Upton and Ramirez is a great deal for you. Im down on Upton at this point because of his strikeout rate, but Reyes impending DL trip and Ramirez's hints at a breakout make it worth it for me.

Help?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=386949

[LMack]

In a non-keeper league this trade would probably be less tasteful, but as you said a sinking ship of a team could look to acquire Reyes. If you can grab onto A Ram right now it would probably be a good move for you to make. Without knowing the teams I like it.

[Delino Deshields]

If not very experimented in keeper leagues but Reyes is a stud . I would keep him. He still have some great years in front of him

[Yank3ez]

Upton and Ramirez is a great trade for you, Ramirez is breaking out of his slump as I have been hoping he would after the benching.

Thanks for the help

[sigriffey]

Totally worth it ... any question marks about Upton are just as much on Reyes, and Ramirez has the upside too.