HUGE TRADE PROPOSED Ibanez/Hamilton WHIR

[Hustler8800]

I was offered 2 trades today.
Trade 1: My Raul Ibanez/Justin Upton for Chipper Jones/Josh Hamilton
Trade 2: My Raul Ibanez for Josh Hamilton

Here is my team:
C: J Salty
1B: R Howard
2B: K Johnson
3B: E Longoria
SS: J Reyes
OF:Raul Ibanez
OF:Justin Upton
OF:BJ Upton
Util: J Bruce
Bn:M Reynolds
Bn:M Weiters
Bn:D Fowler

I think that I am leaning towards doing one of the deals, but I cannot decide if I like the solidness of a healthy Chipper or the upside of the younger Upton more. I do believe I like Hamilton more than Ibanez. What would do? 5x5 HTH standard league.

[FantasyStud]

If you were committed to doing one of the deals, I would pick Deal 2. Chipper's health is risky, and with Longoria at 3B, it's not as if you need a 3B.

Nice team by the way!

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=386896 Thanks!