Is Reynolds in Zimmerman's Range? WHIR

[jmcampbe11]

10 team roto league and my only real weakness is batting avg. The other team is strong in batting avg, but needs hrs/rbis. What do you think it would take to even out this trade offer and convince him to swap Reynolds for Zimmerman?

GIVE - Reynolds and ???

GET - Zimmerman and ???

MY TEAM
C-Martin
1b-A.Gonzalez 3b-Longoria
2b-Phillips ss-Alx.Ramirez
CI-Reynolds MI-Zobrist U-Crisp (or Reimold)
OF-Sizemore, Hamilton, Ad.Jones, Dye, V.Wells

HIS TEAM
C-Mauer
1b-M.Cabrera 3b-Zimmerman
2b-Kendrick ss-A.Cabrera
CI-N.Johnson MI-Callaspo U-Cust
OF-Markakis, V.Guerrero, Choo, Abreu, Kubel
Bench-Rasmus, Parra

[FantasyStud]

His team is pretty good - his biggest weakness would be up the middle. With Brandon Phillips injured, you're not exactly strong up the middle. How do your pitchers differ???

Thanks for your help with mine! viewtopic.php?f=26&t=386896

[jmcampbe11]

His team is pretty good - his biggest weakness would be up the middle. With Brandon Phillips injured, you're not exactly strong up the middle. How do your pitchers differ???

Thanks for your help with mine! viewtopic.php?f=26&t=386896

I'm hoping Phillips will play through his injury. Maybe the other owner would see Zobrist as a power upgrade over A.Cabrera?

Here are our pitchers -

HIS
SP-Lineceum, Halladay, Lackey, Halladay, Richmond
RP-Lidge, Bell, Ziegler, Downs, J.Nelson

MINE
SP-Greinke, Gallardo, Carpenter, Lilly, Jimenez, Smoltz
RP-Broxton, Qualls, Percival, Wheeler, Morrow

[Tis]

He gets to count Halladays stats TWICE?

Unfortunately your pitchers seem to be the underrated, breakout types, while his he paid full value for, so it will be harder to get him to buy in. Also, since its a 10 teamer, you both have a lot of studs. You could add a higher value set of players in, but then that changes the focus of the trade.

Easiest place to add a little value would be in RP. Maybe adding in a Qualls for Ziegler swap.

Your RP is bad enough though that I wouldn't really want to do that. Given that Sizemore and Hamilton have to come around and bump their averages up a bit, I'd probably not worry about that trade if it really is simply for average.