I wouldn't start any of those guys over Utley.
I didn't until about 2 weeks ago. I guess it's just based on the stats my league keeps up with (8 offensive categories total). I get plenty of HR & RBI from my 1B, 3B, & OF and these three guys have performed better than Utley in the other categories (H, R, 2B, ave.) over the last couple of weeks. But I'm probably going to take out Scutaro before too long & get Utley or Mike Lowell back in.
Just never would have thought I couldn't find a spot for Utley in my line-up. Guess that's a good thing.