Utley for Braun huge 10 man deal

[Mathew11.]

TEAM A: Braun, Hudson, Mccann, C.Young (SP of Padres) and Sherrill

TEAM B: Kemp, Utley, Posada, Haren and Broxton


Who wins and Y???????

[Mathew11.]

PLZ help guys

[RRGL1]

I vote B, however it would be helpful to know settings (h2h, #of teams, keeper, categories, 1C or 2, MI???). But...

Braun > Kemp (not by a ton though)
Hudson<<<<Utley (not even close)
McCann>>Posada (but at C, not a huge downgrade)
Young<<<Haren (not really close)
Sherrill<<<Broxton (Broxton should be a top-5, if not 3, closer this season)

[bjmacdow]

a five for five trade! that is a bit over the top on its own. I agree with the analysis. Team b wins.

[Diamond Miners]

I vote B, however it would be helpful to know settings (h2h, #of teams, keeper, categories, 1C or 2, MI???). But...

Braun > Kemp (not by a ton though)
Hudson<<<<Utley (not even close)
McCann>>Posada (but at C, not a huge downgrade)
Young<<<Haren (not really close)
Sherrill<<<Broxton (Broxton should be a top-5, if not 3, closer this season)

Good thoughts.

[APAP]

Team B

[REBEL5 AC]

I vote B, however it would be helpful to know settings (h2h, #of teams, keeper, categories, 1C or 2, MI???). But...

Braun > Kemp (not by a ton though)
Hudson<<<<Utley (not even close)
McCann>>Posada (but at C, not a huge downgrade)
Young<<<Haren (not really close)
Sherrill<<<Broxton (Broxton should be a top-5, if not 3, closer this season)

Second this...