I'd be getting the 3 players. I hate Pedroia as there isnt a more overrated player in the league in my opinion. Plus I'd have to drop someone to do it. I am, however, considering a counter of Holliday for Billingsley. He needs a little OF power, and I could use a reliable pitcher. Thoughts on the original and the counter offer would be appreciated and reciprocated.
H2H, 5x5, 15-player keeper league.
1B Pujols, Morneau
SS Alexei Ramirez (2B), Hardy
OF Braun, Holliday, Crawford, Bruce, NCruz, Pence
C VMartinez, Wieters
SP Lincecum, Carpenter, Myers, ESantana, Scherzer, Price, Bush, Hanson
RP Fuentes, Hoffman, Francisco