Grade these pitchers

[Tigers1223]

How do you like these pitchers for the rest of the season

Scherzer
Lester
Zambrano
Oswalt
Wandy Rodriguez
Bedard

Do you think that Bedard can hold up? Of the first 3 or 4, who do you think will finish with the best season?

[Tigers1223]

How about just the first 3 above???

[BigL531]

Probably belongs in the DTKW forum but I'd say they'll finish this way. I think wandy is legit. Not top 10 SP legit, but probably top 20.

Wandy
Lester
Oswalt
Bedard
Scherzer
Zambrano

[Tigers1223]

I am not picking these guys up or trading, just curious what people are predicting regarding bounce backs etc./for real early starts

[activechamp2006]

First tier
Bedard (finally healthy and is the clear cut leader)

2nd tier
Wandy Rodriguez
Roy Oswalt

3rd tier
Scherzer (Underrated. With more run support he could be a top 15 pitcher.)
Lester
Zambrano

[Jays for Days]

Scherzer has run support problems I guess but his main problem is throwing too many pitches. He's usually up to 100 after 5 or 6 innings, making it difficult to max out his W/K potential. The guy is K/IP but he doesn't pitch enough innings to be a true stud yet.

[skones]

Bedard
Wandy Rodriguez
Oswalt
Lester
Scherzer
Zambrano