Sabathia/Kinsler/Cantu for Longoria/Cano WHIR!

[mjago410]

I was offered this trade
I get: Sabathia, Kinsler and Cantu
I give: Longoria and Cano

My roster
C: Bengie Molina
1B: Todd Helton
2B: Robinson Cano
SS: Hanley Ramirez
3B: Evan Longoria
LF: Matt Holliday
CF: Carlos Beltran
RF: Adam Dunn
OF: Juan Pierre
Util: Mark Reynolds (3B)
BN: Jorge Posada
BN: J.J. Hardy (SS)
BN: James Loney (1B)
BN: Corey Hart (OF)

SP: Jake Peavy
SP: Matt Garza
RP: Mariano Rivera
RP: Jonathan Papelbon
P: Erik Bedard
P: Jered Weaver
P: Yovani Gallardo
BN: Ryan Dempster
BN: Francisco Liriano

His Team
C: Russel Martin
1B: Adrian Gonzalez
2B: Ian Kinsler
3B: Jorge Cantu
SS: Rafael Furcal
LF: Raul Ibanez
CF: Ichiro Suzuki
RF: Brad Hawpe
OF: Nyjer Morgan
Util: Marco Scutaro
BN: Daniel Murphy

SP: Johan Santana
SP: CC Sabathia
RP: Brian Fuentes
RP: Ryan Franklin
P: John Saunders
P: Rich Harden
P: Mark Buerhle
BN: Scott Downs
BN: John Maine
BN: Dice-K
BN: Gil Meche
BN: Mike Pelfrey

Is this a good deal? If not, do you suggest any counter offers? Categories are Hits, Runs, HRs, RBIs, BB Avg., SBs, Wins, ERA, Saves, Ks, WHIP
WHIR WHIR
Util:

[SDKSman]

DUH DO IT gotta do it

[RyeWhiskey]

I'd make that trade.
Kinsler > Longoria
CC > Cano
and you get Cantu.

Makes sense.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=386585

[clarkw267]

Longoria is the best player in the deal so if it's a keeper I'd be hesitant, but I'd probably still make the trade.

[davdav]

do that deal! quick!

[BALCO All-Stars]

Longoria is the best player in the deal so if it's a keeper I'd be hesitant, but I'd probably still make the trade.

I'd do the trade, but IMO Kinsler is the best fantasy player in that deal (i'll take the stud 2B over the stud 3B). In any event though, Kinsler and Longoria are a wash, and although I like Cano, CC and Cantu > Cano...

[woowoo crew]

wow, yes i'd do it. at first, i thought you were offering kinsler and co. for longoria & cano. but you getting these 3 for longoria and cano, yes!!

help me please: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=386603

[clarkw267]

Longoria is the best player in the deal so if it's a keeper I'd be hesitant, but I'd probably still make the trade.

I'd do the trade, but IMO Kinsler is the best fantasy player in that deal (i'll take the stud 2B over the stud 3B). In any event though, Kinsler and Longoria are a wash, and although I like Cano, CC and Cantu > Cano...

If there was a draft today I would bet Longoria would go before Kinsler in most drafts. He has more upside, is less of a durability risk, and is just a more talented hitter in general.

[lilfrier]

Yeah, and 3B is pretty shallow this year with A-Ram out and Atkins being a turd, while a lot of 2Bs like Hudson and Hill have shown up. I'd take Longoria. Do the deal though.